File No. 135 against No. 129
Justworks vs Gusto: what each costs
Justworks and Gusto both run US payroll and both bill a monthly base fee plus a fee for each person paid. The difference in how they bill: Justworks charges contractors a separate rate, while Gusto bills US contractors at the plan's per-person fee in months they are paid.
The short answer. Justworks vs Gusto on price: Gusto Simple costs less at every team size, $49 a month plus $6 per person against Justworks Payroll at $50 plus $8 per employee, so the gap grows by the difference in per-person fees with each hire. Gusto Simple covers one state; multi-state payroll starts on Plus. Files checked 10 and 12 Oct 2026.
What each one costs
Every figure below is read from the two price files at the moment this page loads, so this page cannot drift away from them. Each row links to the vendor page the price came from.
| Plan | Price | Billed | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Justworks From $8/employee/mo + $50/mo base fee | ||||
| Payroll | $8/employee/mo + $50/mo base fee | per month: a fee for each employee plus a base fee | Vendor page | |
| PEO Basic | $79/employee/mo | per month, no base fee | Vendor page | |
| PEO Plus | $124/employee/mo | per month, no base fee | Vendor page | |
| EOR | $599/employee/mo | per month, no base fee | Vendor page | |
| Gusto From $49/mo + $6/person/mo | ||||
| Simple | $49/mo + $6/person/mo | per month: a base fee plus a fee for each person paid | Vendor page | |
| Plus | $80/mo + $12/person/mo | per month: a base fee plus a fee for each person paid | Vendor page | |
| Premium | $180/mo + $22/person/mo | per month: a base fee plus a fee for each person paid | Vendor page | |
| Solo | $49/mo + $6/person/mo | per month: a base fee plus a fee for each person paid | Vendor page | |
Which one is for you
Pick Justworks if the company wants a PEO, with PEO Basic at $79 or PEO Plus at $124 per employee per month and no base fee, or needs employer of record hiring abroad.
Pick Gusto if the goal is the lowest payroll-only bill: Simple at $49 a month plus $6 per person, or Plus at $80 plus $12 for payroll in more than one state.
What Justworks's pricing page does not say
- The Payroll plan's $8 per employee is on top of a $50 per month base fee, so one employee costs $58 a month. The PEO plans and EOR have no base fee.
- Justworks Time Tracking is a priced add-on at $8 per month per employee. The plan cards list access to Time Tracking, and the add-on is available in the Payroll, Basic and Plus plans.
- Contractors are charged separately: $8 per month per paid US-based contractor and $39 per month per paid international contractor.
- On the Payroll plan, access to medical, dental and vision insurance plus COBRA administration is an add-on at $8 per month per benefits-eligible employee. The insurance premiums themselves are not priced on the page.
- Dedicated HR Consulting is $30 per month per employee, available in the Basic and Plus plans. Health Insurance Reimbursements (CHOICE) is $25 per month per enrolled employee.
- The page lists the questions on billing, minimum number of employees and plan switching, but their answers were not read in this check.
What Gusto's pricing page does not say
- The large figure on each card is only the base fee. Every plan adds a per-person fee each month: $6 on Simple, $12 on Plus and $22 on Premium.
- Simple is described as payroll in one state. Multi-state payroll starts at Plus.
- State tax registration is an add-on, and the page says its pricing varies by state.
- Faster pay costs extra below Premium. Same-day pay is $90 per payroll and Instant pay is $100 per payroll on Simple and Plus. Next-Day pay is an add-on on Simple, printed on the page as $15/mo + 3/mo per person.
- Priority Support is an add-on at $30/mo + $3/mo per person on Simple and Plus.
- Gusto Business Compliance is $85/mo per state on an annual contract for Simple and Plus, and is included in Premium.
- Tax-advantaged benefits carry a $200 annual service charge, plus $2.50/mo per participant for HSAs and $4/mo per participant ($20/mo minimum) for FSAs, dependent care FSAs and commuter benefits.
- Contractors count toward the per-person fee. The page's answer on contractor billing says US contractors are billed at the plan's per-person cost, only in months when they are paid. Payments to global contractors carry no monthly per-contractor fee, but a service and foreign exchange fee per payment.
Justworks vs Gusto cost per employee
Both bills are a base fee plus a fee per person. The table sets out the monthly sum for 1, 10 and 25 employees on the entry plans, before taxes and add-ons; each line is the base fee plus head count times the per-person fee.
| Employees | Justworks Payroll | Gusto Simple | Gusto Plus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $50 + 1 x $8 | $49 + 1 x $6 | $80 + 1 x $12 |
| 10 | $50 + 10 x $8 | $49 + 10 x $6 | $80 + 10 x $12 |
| 25 | $50 + 25 x $8 | $49 + 25 x $6 | $80 + 25 x $12 |
The base fees differ by one dollar, so the gap comes from the per-person rate: $8 at Justworks against $6 on Gusto Simple, which adds up with every employee. Gusto Simple is described as payroll in one state, so a team spread across states compares Justworks Payroll with Gusto Plus, where Justworks costs less.
Contractor charges
- Justworks charges $8 per month per paid US-based contractor, and a higher monthly fee per paid international contractor, set out in its price file.
- Gusto bills US contractors at the plan's per-person fee ($6 on Simple, $12 on Plus), only in months when they are paid. Global contractor payments carry a service and foreign exchange fee instead of a monthly fee.
Other billing differences
- PEO. Justworks sells PEO plans with no base fee, from $79 per employee per month. Gusto's file lists no PEO plan.
- Add-ons. Justworks Time Tracking is $8 per employee per month. On Gusto, time tracking is included from Plus.
The full tables are in Justworks' price file and Gusto's price file. Other payroll tools are in the payroll drawer.
The evidence
Both vendors' pricing pages, as they looked when the figures were read.
Figures on this page come from the two files named above, each read off the vendor's own pricing page on the date shown. Prices change without notice; check before buying.